docs/compat.md

# Standards conformance {#compat_guide}

[TOC]

This guide describes the various API extensions used by this version of GLFW.
It lists what are essentially implementation details, but which are nonetheless
vital knowledge for developers intending to deploy their applications on a wide
range of machines.

The information in this guide is not a part of GLFW API, but merely
preconditions for some parts of the library to function on a given machine.  Any
part of this information may change in future versions of GLFW and that will not
be considered a breaking API change.


## X11 extensions, protocols and IPC standards {#compat_x11}

As GLFW uses Xlib directly, without any intervening toolkit library, it has sole
responsibility for interacting well with the many and varied window managers in
use on Unix-like systems.  In order for applications and window managers to work
well together, a number of standards and conventions have been developed that
regulate behavior outside the scope of the X11 API; most importantly the
[Inter-Client Communication Conventions Manual][ICCCM] (ICCCM) and [Extended
Window Manager Hints][EWMH] (EWMH) standards.

[ICCCM]: https://www.tronche.com/gui/x/icccm/
[EWMH]: https://standards.freedesktop.org/wm-spec/wm-spec-latest.html

GLFW uses the `_MOTIF_WM_HINTS` window property to support borderless windows.
If the running window manager does not support this property, the
`GLFW_DECORATED` hint will have no effect.

GLFW uses the ICCCM `WM_DELETE_WINDOW` protocol to intercept the user
attempting to close the GLFW window.  If the running window manager does not
support this protocol, the close callback will never be called.

GLFW uses the EWMH `_NET_WM_PING` protocol, allowing the window manager notify
the user when the application has stopped responding, i.e. when it has ceased to
process events.  If the running window manager does not support this protocol,
the user will not be notified if the application locks up.

GLFW uses the EWMH `_NET_WM_STATE_FULLSCREEN` window state to tell the window
manager to make the GLFW window full screen.  If the running window manager does
not support this state, full screen windows may not work properly.  GLFW has
a fallback code path in case this state is unavailable, but every window manager
behaves slightly differently in this regard.

GLFW uses the EWMH `_NET_WM_BYPASS_COMPOSITOR` window property to tell a
compositing window manager to un-redirect full screen GLFW windows.  If the
running window manager uses compositing but does not support this property then
additional copying may be performed for each buffer swap of full screen windows.

GLFW uses the [clipboard manager protocol][ClipboardManager] to keep the
clipboard string availble for the user after the libary has been terminated.  If
there is no running clipboard manager and the clipboard contents has been set
with @ref glfwSetClipboardString, the clipboard will be emptied when the library
is terminated.

[clipboardManager]: https://www.freedesktop.org/wiki/ClipboardManager/

GLFW uses the [X drag-and-drop protocol][XDND] to provide file drop events.  If
the application originating the drag does not support this protocol, drag and
drop will not work.

[XDND]: https://www.freedesktop.org/wiki/Specifications/XDND/

GLFW uses the XRandR 1.3 extension to provide multi-monitor support.  If the
running X server does not support this version of this extension, multi-monitor
support will not function and only a single, desktop-spanning monitor will be
reported.

GLFW uses the XRandR 1.3 and Xf86vidmode extensions to provide gamma ramp
support.  If the running X server does not support either or both of these
extensions, gamma ramp support will not function.

GLFW uses the Xkb extension and detectable auto-repeat to provide keyboard
input.  If the running X server does not support this extension, a non-Xkb
fallback path is used.

GLFW uses the XInput2 extension to provide raw, non-accelerated mouse motion
when the cursor is disabled.  If the running X server does not support this
extension, regular accelerated mouse motion will be used.

GLFW uses both the XRender extension and the compositing manager to support
transparent window framebuffers.  If the running X server does not support this
extension or there is no running compositing manager, the
`GLFW_TRANSPARENT_FRAMEBUFFER` framebuffer hint will have no effect.

GLFW uses both the Xcursor extension and the freedesktop cursor conventions to
provide an expanded set of standard cursor shapes.  If the running X server does
not support this extension or the current cursor theme does not support the
conventions, the `GLFW_RESIZE_NWSE_CURSOR`, `GLFW_RESIZE_NESW_CURSOR` and
`GLFW_NOT_ALLOWED_CURSOR` shapes will not be available and other shapes may use
legacy images.


## Wayland protocols and IPC standards {#compat_wayland}

As GLFW uses libwayland directly, without any intervening toolkit library, it
has sole responsibility for interacting well with every compositor in use on
Unix-like systems.  Most of the features are provided by the core protocol,
while cursor support is provided by the libwayland-cursor helper library, EGL
integration by libwayland-egl, and keyboard handling by
[libxkbcommon](https://xkbcommon.org/).  In addition, GLFW uses some additional
Wayland protocols to implement certain features if the compositor supports them.

GLFW uses xkbcommon 0.5.0 to provide key and text input support.  Earlier
versions are not supported.

GLFW uses the [xdg-shell][] protocol to provide better window management.  This
protocol is mandatory for GLFW to display a window.

[xdg-shell]: https://wayland.app/protocols/xdg-shell

GLFW uses the [relative-pointer-unstable-v1][] protocol alongside the
[pointer-constraints-unstable-v1][] protocol to implement disabled cursor.  If
the running compositor does not support both of these protocols, disabling the
cursor will have no effect.

[relative-pointer-unstable-v1]: https://wayland.app/protocols/relative-pointer-unstable-v1
[pointer-constraints-unstable-v1]: https://wayland.app/protocols/pointer-constraints-unstable-v1

GLFW uses the [idle-inhibit-unstable-v1][] protocol to prohibit the screensaver
from starting.  If the running compositor does not support this protocol, the
screensaver may start even for full screen windows.

[idle-inhibit-unstable-v1]: https://wayland.app/protocols/idle-inhibit-unstable-v1

GLFW uses the [libdecor][] library for window decorations, where available.
This in turn provides good quality client-side decorations (drawn by the
application) on desktop systems that do not support server-side decorations
(drawn by the window manager).  On systems that do not provide either libdecor
or xdg-decoration, very basic window decorations are provided.  These do not
include the window title or any caption buttons.

[libdecor]: https://gitlab.freedesktop.org/libdecor/libdecor

GLFW uses the [xdg-decoration-unstable-v1][] protocol to request decorations to
be drawn around its windows.  This protocol is part of wayland-protocols 1.15,
and mandatory at build time.  If the running compositor does not support this
protocol, a very simple frame will be drawn by GLFW itself, using the
[viewporter][] protocol alongside subsurfaces.  If the running compositor does
not support these protocols either, no decorations will be drawn around windows.

[xdg-decoration-unstable-v1]: https://wayland.app/protocols/xdg-decoration-unstable-v1
[viewporter]: https://wayland.app/protocols/viewporter

GLFW uses the [xdg-activation-v1][] protocol to implement window focus and
attention requests.  If the running compositor does not support this protocol,
window focus and attention requests do nothing.

[xdg-activation-v1]: https://wayland.app/protocols/xdg-activation-v1

GLFW uses the [fractional-scale-v1][] protocol to implement fine-grained
framebuffer scaling.  If the running compositor does not support this protocol,
the @ref GLFW_SCALE_FRAMEBUFFER window hint will only be able to scale the
framebuffer by integer scales.  This will typically be the smallest integer not
less than the actual scale.

[fractional-scale-v1]: https://wayland.app/protocols/fractional-scale-v1


## GLX extensions {#compat_glx}

The GLX API is the default API used to create OpenGL contexts on Unix-like
systems using the X Window System.

GLFW uses the GLX 1.3 `GLXFBConfig` functions to enumerate and select framebuffer pixel
formats.  If GLX 1.3 is not supported, @ref glfwInit will fail.

GLFW uses the `GLX_MESA_swap_control,` `GLX_EXT_swap_control` and
`GLX_SGI_swap_control` extensions to provide vertical retrace synchronization
(or _vsync_), in that order of preference.  When none of these extensions are
available, calling @ref glfwSwapInterval will have no effect.

GLFW uses the `GLX_ARB_multisample` extension to create contexts with
multisampling anti-aliasing.  Where this extension is unavailable, the
`GLFW_SAMPLES` hint will have no effect.

GLFW uses the `GLX_ARB_create_context` extension when available, even when
creating OpenGL contexts of version 2.1 and below.  Where this extension is
unavailable, the `GLFW_CONTEXT_VERSION_MAJOR` and `GLFW_CONTEXT_VERSION_MINOR`
hints will only be partially supported, the `GLFW_CONTEXT_DEBUG` hint will have
no effect, and setting the `GLFW_OPENGL_PROFILE` or `GLFW_OPENGL_FORWARD_COMPAT`
hints to `GLFW_TRUE` will cause @ref glfwCreateWindow to fail.

GLFW uses the `GLX_ARB_create_context_profile` extension to provide support for
context profiles.  Where this extension is unavailable, setting the
`GLFW_OPENGL_PROFILE` hint to anything but `GLFW_OPENGL_ANY_PROFILE`, or setting
`GLFW_CLIENT_API` to anything but `GLFW_OPENGL_API` or `GLFW_NO_API` will cause
@ref glfwCreateWindow to fail.

GLFW uses the `GLX_ARB_context_flush_control` extension to provide control over
whether a context is flushed when it is released (made non-current).  Where this
extension is unavailable, the `GLFW_CONTEXT_RELEASE_BEHAVIOR` hint will have no
effect and the context will always be flushed when released.

GLFW uses the `GLX_ARB_framebuffer_sRGB` and `GLX_EXT_framebuffer_sRGB`
extensions to provide support for sRGB framebuffers.  Where both of these
extensions are unavailable, the `GLFW_SRGB_CAPABLE` hint will have no effect.


## WGL extensions {#compat_wgl}

The WGL API is used to create OpenGL contexts on Microsoft Windows and other
implementations of the Win32 API, such as Wine.

GLFW uses either the `WGL_EXT_extension_string` or the
`WGL_ARB_extension_string` extension to check for the presence of all other WGL
extensions listed below.  If both are available, the EXT one is preferred.  If
neither is available, no other extensions are used and many GLFW features
related to context creation will have no effect or cause errors when used.

GLFW uses the `WGL_EXT_swap_control` extension to provide vertical retrace
synchronization (or _vsync_).  Where this extension is unavailable, calling @ref
glfwSwapInterval will have no effect.

GLFW uses the `WGL_ARB_pixel_format` and `WGL_ARB_multisample` extensions to
create contexts with multisampling anti-aliasing.  Where these extensions are
unavailable, the `GLFW_SAMPLES` hint will have no effect.

GLFW uses the `WGL_ARB_create_context` extension when available, even when
creating OpenGL contexts of version 2.1 and below.  Where this extension is
unavailable, the `GLFW_CONTEXT_VERSION_MAJOR` and `GLFW_CONTEXT_VERSION_MINOR`
hints will only be partially supported, the `GLFW_CONTEXT_DEBUG` hint will have
no effect, and setting the `GLFW_OPENGL_PROFILE` or `GLFW_OPENGL_FORWARD_COMPAT`
hints to `GLFW_TRUE` will cause @ref glfwCreateWindow to fail.

GLFW uses the `WGL_ARB_create_context_profile` extension to provide support for
context profiles.  Where this extension is unavailable, setting the
`GLFW_OPENGL_PROFILE` hint to anything but `GLFW_OPENGL_ANY_PROFILE` will cause
@ref glfwCreateWindow to fail.

GLFW uses the `WGL_ARB_context_flush_control` extension to provide control over
whether a context is flushed when it is released (made non-current).  Where this
extension is unavailable, the `GLFW_CONTEXT_RELEASE_BEHAVIOR` hint will have no
effect and the context will always be flushed when released.

GLFW uses the `WGL_ARB_framebuffer_sRGB` and `WGL_EXT_framebuffer_sRGB`
extensions to provide support for sRGB framebuffers.  When both of these
extensions are unavailable, the `GLFW_SRGB_CAPABLE` hint will have no effect.


## OpenGL on macOS {#compat_osx}

macOS (as of version 14) still provides OpenGL but it has been deprecated by
Apple.  While the API is still available, it is poorly maintained and frequently
develops new issues.  On modern systems, OpenGL is implemented on top of Metal
and is not fully thread-safe.

macOS does not support OpenGL stereo rendering.  If the `GLFW_STEREO` hint is
set to true, OpenGL context creation will always fail.

macOS only supports OpenGL core profile contexts that are forward-compatible,
but the `GLFW_OPENGL_FORWARD_COMPAT` hint is ignored since GLFW 3.4.  Even if
this hint is set to false (the default), a forward-compatible context will be
returned if available.

macOS does not support OpenGL debug contexts, no-error contexts or robustness.
The `GLFW_CONTEXT_DEBUG`, `GLFW_CONTEXT_NO_ERROR` and `GLFW_CONTEXT_ROBUSTNESS`
hints will be ignored and a context without these features will be returned.

macOS does not flush OpenGL contexts when they are made non-current.  The
`GLFW_CONTEXT_RELEASE_BEHAVIOR` hint is ignored and the release behavior will
always be the equivalent of `GLFW_RELEASE_BEHAVIOR_NONE`.  If you need a context
to be flushed, call `glFlush` before making it non-current.


## Vulkan loader and API {#compat_vulkan}

By default, GLFW uses the standard system-wide Vulkan loader to access the
Vulkan API on all platforms except macOS.  This is installed by both graphics
drivers and Vulkan SDKs.  If either the loader or at least one minimally
functional ICD is missing, @ref glfwVulkanSupported will return `GLFW_FALSE` and
all other Vulkan-related functions will fail with an @ref GLFW_API_UNAVAILABLE
error.


## Vulkan WSI extensions {#compat_wsi}

The Vulkan WSI extensions are used to create Vulkan surfaces for GLFW windows on
all supported platforms.

GLFW uses the `VK_KHR_surface` and `VK_KHR_win32_surface` extensions to create
surfaces on Microsoft Windows.  If any of these extensions are not available,
@ref glfwGetRequiredInstanceExtensions will return an empty list and window
surface creation will fail.

GLFW uses the `VK_KHR_surface` and either the `VK_MVK_macos_surface` or
`VK_EXT_metal_surface` extensions to create surfaces on macOS.  If any of these
extensions are not available, @ref glfwGetRequiredInstanceExtensions will
return an empty list and window surface creation will fail.

GLFW uses the `VK_KHR_surface` and either the `VK_KHR_xlib_surface` or
`VK_KHR_xcb_surface` extensions to create surfaces on X11.  If `VK_KHR_surface`
or both `VK_KHR_xlib_surface` and `VK_KHR_xcb_surface` are not available, @ref
glfwGetRequiredInstanceExtensions will return an empty list and window surface
creation will fail.

GLFW uses the `VK_KHR_surface` and `VK_KHR_wayland_surface` extensions to create
surfaces on Wayland.  If any of these extensions are not available, @ref
glfwGetRequiredInstanceExtensions will return an empty list and window surface
creation will fail.