auto_submit/test/service/validation_service_test.dart

// Copyright 2022 The Flutter Authors. All rights reserved.
// Use of this source code is governed by a BSD-style license that can be
// found in the LICENSE file.

import 'dart:async';
import 'dart:convert';

import 'package:auto_submit/model/auto_submit_query_result.dart' as auto hide PullRequest;
import 'package:auto_submit/service/process_method.dart';
import 'package:auto_submit/service/validation_service.dart';
import 'package:auto_submit/validations/validation.dart';
import 'package:github/github.dart';
import 'package:googleapis/bigquery/v2.dart';
import 'package:graphql/client.dart';
import 'package:mockito/mockito.dart';
import 'package:retry/retry.dart';
import 'package:test/test.dart';

import '../requests/github_webhook_test_data.dart';
import '../src/request_handling/fake_pubsub.dart';
import '../src/service/fake_approver_service.dart';
import '../src/service/fake_bigquery_service.dart';
import '../src/service/fake_config.dart';
import '../src/service/fake_graphql_client.dart';
import '../src/service/fake_github_service.dart';
import '../src/validations/fake_revert.dart';
import '../utilities/utils.dart';
import '../utilities/mocks.dart';
import 'bigquery_test.dart';

void main() {
  late ValidationService validationService;
  late FakeConfig config;
  late FakeGithubService githubService;
  late FakeGraphQLClient githubGraphQLClient;
  late RepositorySlug slug;

  late MockJobsResource jobsResource;
  late FakeBigqueryService bigqueryService;

  setUp(() {
    githubGraphQLClient = FakeGraphQLClient();
    githubService = FakeGithubService(client: MockGitHub());
    config = FakeConfig(githubService: githubService, githubGraphQLClient: githubGraphQLClient);
    validationService = ValidationService(
      config,
      retryOptions: const RetryOptions(delayFactor: Duration.zero, maxDelay: Duration.zero, maxAttempts: 1),
    );
    slug = RepositorySlug('flutter', 'cocoon');

    jobsResource = MockJobsResource();
    bigqueryService = FakeBigqueryService(jobsResource);
    config.bigqueryService = bigqueryService;

    when(jobsResource.query(captureAny, any)).thenAnswer((Invocation invocation) {
      return Future<QueryResponse>.value(
        QueryResponse.fromJson(jsonDecode(insertDeleteUpdateSuccessResponse) as Map<dynamic, dynamic>),
      );
    });
  });

  test('Removes label and post comment when no approval', () async {
    final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
      prNumber: 0,
      lastCommitHash: oid,
      reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
    );
    githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
    githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
    final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
    final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(prNumber: 0, repoName: slug.name);
    unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
    final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

    await validationService.processPullRequest(
      config: config,
      result: queryResult,
      messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
      ackId: 'test',
      pubsub: pubsub,
    );

    expect(githubService.issueComment, isNotNull);
    expect(githubService.labelRemoved, true);
    assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
  });

  test('Remove label and post comment when no revert label.', () async {
    final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
      prNumber: 0,
      lastCommitHash: oid,
      reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
    );
    githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
    githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
    final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
    final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
      prNumber: 0,
      repoName: slug.name,
    );
    unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
    final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

    await validationService.processRevertRequest(
      config: config,
      result: queryResult,
      messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
      ackId: 'test',
      pubsub: pubsub,
    );

    expect(githubService.issueComment, isNotNull);
    expect(githubService.labelRemoved, true);
    assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
  });

  group('Processing revert reqeuests.', () {
    test('Merge valid revert request, issue created and message is acknowledged.', () async {
      final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
        prNumber: 0,
        lastCommitHash: oid,
        reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
      );

      githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
      githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
      githubService.mergeRequestMock = PullRequestMerge(
        merged: true,
        sha: 'sha',
        message: 'Pull Request successfully merged',
      );

      final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
        prNumber: 0,
        repoName: slug.name,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
        labelName: 'revert',
        body: 'Reverts flutter/flutter#1234',
      );

      final FakeRevert fakeRevert = FakeRevert(config: config);
      fakeRevert.validationResult = ValidationResult(true, Action.REMOVE_LABEL, '');
      validationService.revertValidation = fakeRevert;
      final FakeApproverService fakeApproverService = FakeApproverService(config);
      validationService.approverService = fakeApproverService;

      final Issue issue = Issue(
        id: 1234,
        assignee: User(login: 'keyonghan'),
        createdAt: DateTime.now(),
      );
      githubService.githubIssueMock = issue;
      githubService.pullRequestMock = pullRequest;

      unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
      final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

      await validationService.processRevertRequest(
        config: config,
        result: queryResult,
        messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
        ackId: 'test',
        pubsub: pubsub,
      );

      // if the merge is successful we do not remove the label and we do not add a comment to the issue.
      expect(githubService.issueComment, isNull);
      expect(githubService.labelRemoved, false);
      // We acknowledge the issue.
      assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
    });

    test('Fail to merge non valid revert, issue not created, comment is added and message is acknowledged.', () async {
      githubGraphQLClient.mutateResultForOptions = (MutationOptions options) => createFakeQueryResult();
      final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
        prNumber: 0,
        lastCommitHash: oid,
        reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
      );

      githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
      githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
      final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
        prNumber: 0,
        repoName: slug.name,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
        labelName: 'revert',
        body: 'Reverts flutter/flutter#1234',
      );

      final FakeRevert fakeRevert = FakeRevert(config: config);
      fakeRevert.validationResult = ValidationResult(false, Action.REMOVE_LABEL, '');
      validationService.revertValidation = fakeRevert;
      final FakeApproverService fakeApproverService = FakeApproverService(config);
      validationService.approverService = fakeApproverService;

      unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
      final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

      await validationService.processRevertRequest(
        config: config,
        result: queryResult,
        messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
        ackId: 'test',
        pubsub: pubsub,
      );

      // if the merge is successful we do not remove the label and we do not add a comment to the issue.
      expect(githubService.issueComment, isNotNull);
      expect(githubService.labelRemoved, true);
      // We acknowledge the issue.
      assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
    });

    test('Remove label and post comment when unable to process merge.', () async {
      final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
        prNumber: 0,
        lastCommitHash: oid,
        reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
      );
      githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
      githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
      final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
        prNumber: 0,
        repoName: slug.name,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
        labelName: 'revert',
      );

      final FakeRevert fakeRevert = FakeRevert(config: config);
      fakeRevert.validationResult = ValidationResult(true, Action.REMOVE_LABEL, '');
      validationService.revertValidation = fakeRevert;
      final FakeApproverService fakeApproverService = FakeApproverService(config);
      validationService.approverService = fakeApproverService;

      unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
      final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

      await validationService.processRevertRequest(
        config: config,
        result: queryResult,
        messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
        ackId: 'test',
        pubsub: pubsub,
      );

      expect(githubService.issueComment, isNotNull);
      expect(githubService.labelRemoved, true);
      assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
    });

    test('Fail to create follow up review issue, comment is added and message is acknowledged.', () async {
      final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
        prNumber: 0,
        lastCommitHash: oid,
        reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
      );

      githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
      githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
      githubService.throwOnCreateIssue = true;
      githubService.useRealComment = true;
      githubService.mergeRequestMock = PullRequestMerge(
        merged: true,
        sha: 'sha',
        message: 'Pull Request successfully merged',
      );

      final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
        prNumber: 0,
        repoName: slug.name,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
        labelName: 'revert',
        body: 'Reverts flutter/flutter#1234',
      );

      final FakeRevert fakeRevert = FakeRevert(config: config);
      fakeRevert.validationResult = ValidationResult(true, Action.REMOVE_LABEL, '');
      validationService.revertValidation = fakeRevert;
      final FakeApproverService fakeApproverService = FakeApproverService(config);
      validationService.approverService = fakeApproverService;

      unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
      final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

      await validationService.processRevertRequest(
        config: config,
        result: queryResult,
        messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
        ackId: 'test',
        pubsub: pubsub,
      );

      // if the merge is successful we do not remove the label and we do not add a comment to the issue.
      expect(githubService.issueComment, isNotNull);
      final IssueComment issueComment = githubService.issueComment!;
      assert(issueComment.body!.contains('create the follow up review issue'));
      expect(githubService.labelRemoved, false);
      // We acknowledge the issue.
      assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
    });

    test('Revert returns on in process required checkRuns.', () async {
      githubGraphQLClient.mutateResultForOptions = (MutationOptions options) => createFakeQueryResult();
      final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
        prNumber: 0,
        lastCommitHash: oid,
        reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
      );

      githubService.checkRunsData = inProgressCheckRunsMock;
      githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
      githubService.throwOnCreateIssue = true;
      githubService.useRealComment = true;
      final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
        prNumber: 0,
        repoName: slug.name,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
        labelName: 'revert',
        body: 'Reverts flutter/flutter#1234',
      );

      final FakeRevert fakeRevert = FakeRevert(config: config);
      fakeRevert.validationResult =
          ValidationResult(false, Action.IGNORE_TEMPORARILY, 'Some of the required checks did not complete in time.');
      validationService.revertValidation = fakeRevert;
      final FakeApproverService fakeApproverService = FakeApproverService(config);
      validationService.approverService = fakeApproverService;

      unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
      final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

      await validationService.processRevertRequest(
        config: config,
        result: queryResult,
        messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
        ackId: 'test',
        pubsub: pubsub,
      );

      // if the merge is successful we do not remove the label and we do not add a comment to the issue.
      expect(githubService.issueComment, isNull);
      expect(githubService.labelRemoved, false);
      // We acknowledge the issue.
      assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isNotEmpty);
    });

    test('Exhaust retries on merge on retryable error.', () async {
      validationService = ValidationService(
        config,
        retryOptions: const RetryOptions(
          delayFactor: Duration.zero,
          maxDelay: Duration.zero,
          maxAttempts: 1,
        ),
      );

      githubGraphQLClient.mutateResultForOptions = (MutationOptions options) => createFakeQueryResult(
            exception: OperationException(
              graphqlErrors: [
                const GraphQLError(message: 'Base branch was modified. Review and try the merge again'),
              ],
            ),
          );

      final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
        prNumber: 0,
        lastCommitHash: oid,
        reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
      );

      githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
      githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
      githubService.useRealComment = true;
      final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
        prNumber: 0,
        repoName: slug.name,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
        labelName: 'revert',
        body: 'Reverts flutter/flutter#1234',
      );

      final FakeRevert fakeRevert = FakeRevert(config: config);
      fakeRevert.validationResult = ValidationResult(true, Action.REMOVE_LABEL, '');
      validationService.revertValidation = fakeRevert;
      final FakeApproverService fakeApproverService = FakeApproverService(config);
      validationService.approverService = fakeApproverService;

      final Issue issue = Issue(
        id: 1234,
        assignee: User(login: 'keyonghan'),
        createdAt: DateTime.now(),
      );
      githubService.githubIssueMock = issue;

      unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
      final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

      await validationService.processRevertRequest(
        config: config,
        result: queryResult,
        messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
        ackId: 'test',
        pubsub: pubsub,
      );

      // if the merge is successful we do not remove the label and we do not add a comment to the issue.
      expect(githubService.issueComment, isNotNull);
      expect(githubService.labelRemoved, true);
      // We acknowledge the issue.
      assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
    });

    test('Do not retry merge on non retryable error.', () async {
      githubGraphQLClient.mutateResultForOptions = (MutationOptions options) => createFakeQueryResult(
            exception: OperationException(
              graphqlErrors: [
                const GraphQLError(message: 'Branches have diverged. Request cannot be merged.'),
              ],
            ),
          );
      final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
        prNumber: 0,
        lastCommitHash: oid,
        reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
      );

      githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
      githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
      githubService.useRealComment = true;
      final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
        prNumber: 0,
        repoName: slug.name,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
        labelName: 'revert',
        body: 'Reverts flutter/flutter#1234',
      );

      final FakeRevert fakeRevert = FakeRevert(config: config);
      fakeRevert.validationResult = ValidationResult(true, Action.REMOVE_LABEL, '');
      validationService.revertValidation = fakeRevert;
      final FakeApproverService fakeApproverService = FakeApproverService(config);
      validationService.approverService = fakeApproverService;

      final Issue issue = Issue(
        id: 1234,
        assignee: User(login: 'keyonghan'),
        createdAt: DateTime.now(),
      );
      githubService.githubIssueMock = issue;

      unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
      final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

      await validationService.processRevertRequest(
        config: config,
        result: queryResult,
        messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
        ackId: 'test',
        pubsub: pubsub,
      );

      // if the merge is successful we do not remove the label and we do not add a comment to the issue.
      expect(githubService.issueComment, isNotNull);
      expect(githubService.labelRemoved, true);
      final IssueComment issueComment = githubService.issueComment!;
      expect(issueComment.body!.contains('merge attempts were exhausted'), false);
      expect(issueComment.body!.contains('Failed to merge'), true);
      // We acknowledge the issue.
      assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
    });

    test('Do not retry merge on multiple errors with retryable error.', () async {
      githubGraphQLClient.mutateResultForOptions = (MutationOptions options) => createFakeQueryResult(
            exception: OperationException(
              graphqlErrors: [
                const GraphQLError(message: 'Account does not have merge permissions.'),
                const GraphQLError(message: 'Base branch was modified. Review and try the merge again.')
              ],
            ),
          );

      final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
        prNumber: 0,
        lastCommitHash: oid,
        reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
      );

      githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
      githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
      githubService.useRealComment = true;
      final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
        prNumber: 0,
        repoName: slug.name,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
        labelName: 'revert',
        body: 'Reverts flutter/flutter#1234',
      );

      final FakeRevert fakeRevert = FakeRevert(config: config);
      fakeRevert.validationResult = ValidationResult(true, Action.REMOVE_LABEL, '');
      validationService.revertValidation = fakeRevert;
      final FakeApproverService fakeApproverService = FakeApproverService(config);
      validationService.approverService = fakeApproverService;

      final Issue issue = Issue(
        id: 1234,
        assignee: User(login: 'keyonghan'),
        createdAt: DateTime.now(),
      );
      githubService.githubIssueMock = issue;

      unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
      final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

      await validationService.processRevertRequest(
        config: config,
        result: queryResult,
        messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
        ackId: 'test',
        pubsub: pubsub,
      );

      // if the merge is successful we do not remove the label and we do not add a comment to the issue.
      expect(githubService.issueComment, isNotNull);
      expect(githubService.labelRemoved, true);
      final IssueComment issueComment = githubService.issueComment!;
      expect(issueComment.body!.contains('merge attempts were exhausted'), false);
      expect(issueComment.body!.contains('Failed to merge'), true);
      // We acknowledge the issue.
      assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
    });

    test('Merge fails the first time but then succeeds after retry.', () async {
      validationService = ValidationService(
        config,
        retryOptions: const RetryOptions(
          delayFactor: Duration.zero,
          maxDelay: Duration.zero,
          maxAttempts: 3,
        ),
      );

      githubService.useMergeRequestMockList = true;
      githubService.pullRequestMergeMockList.add(
        PullRequestMerge(
          merged: false,
          message: 'Unable to merge pull request.',
        ),
      );
      githubService.pullRequestMergeMockList.add(
        PullRequestMerge(
          merged: true,
          sha: 'sha',
          message: 'Pull Request successfully merged',
        ),
      );

      final PullRequestHelper flutterRequest = PullRequestHelper(
        prNumber: 0,
        lastCommitHash: oid,
        reviews: <PullRequestReviewHelper>[],
      );

      githubService.checkRunsData = checkRunsMock;
      githubService.createCommentData = createCommentMock;
      githubService.useRealComment = true;

      final FakePubSub pubsub = FakePubSub();
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(
        prNumber: 0,
        repoName: slug.name,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
        labelName: 'revert',
        body: 'Reverts flutter/flutter#1234',
      );

      final FakeRevert fakeRevert = FakeRevert(config: config);
      fakeRevert.validationResult = ValidationResult(true, Action.REMOVE_LABEL, '');
      validationService.revertValidation = fakeRevert;
      final FakeApproverService fakeApproverService = FakeApproverService(config);
      validationService.approverService = fakeApproverService;

      final Issue issue = Issue(
        id: 1234,
        assignee: User(login: 'keyonghan'),
        createdAt: DateTime.now(),
      );
      githubService.githubIssueMock = issue;
      githubService.pullRequestMock = pullRequest;

      unawaited(pubsub.publish('auto-submit-queue-sub', pullRequest));
      final auto.QueryResult queryResult = createQueryResult(flutterRequest);

      await validationService.processRevertRequest(
        config: config,
        result: queryResult,
        messagePullRequest: pullRequest,
        ackId: 'test',
        pubsub: pubsub,
      );

      // if the merge is successful we do not remove the label and we do not add a comment to the issue.
      expect(githubService.issueComment, isNull);
      expect(githubService.labelRemoved, false);
      // We acknowledge the issue.
      assert(pubsub.messagesQueue.isEmpty);
    });
  });

  group('Process pull request', () {
    test('Should process message when autosubmit label exists and pr is open', () async {
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(prNumber: 0, repoName: slug.name);
      githubService.pullRequestData = pullRequest;
      final ProcessMethod processMethod = await validationService.processPullRequestMethod(pullRequest);

      expect(processMethod, ProcessMethod.processAutosubmit);
    });

    test('Skip processing message when autosubmit label does not exist anymore', () async {
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(prNumber: 0, repoName: slug.name);
      pullRequest.labels = <IssueLabel>[];
      githubService.pullRequestData = pullRequest;
      final ProcessMethod processMethod = await validationService.processPullRequestMethod(pullRequest);

      expect(processMethod, ProcessMethod.doNotProcess);
    });

    test('Skip processing message when the pull request is closed', () async {
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(prNumber: 0, repoName: slug.name);
      pullRequest.state = 'closed';
      githubService.pullRequestData = pullRequest;
      final ProcessMethod processMethod = await validationService.processPullRequestMethod(pullRequest);

      expect(processMethod, ProcessMethod.doNotProcess);
    });

    test('Should process message when revert label exists and pr is open', () async {
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(prNumber: 0, repoName: slug.name);
      final IssueLabel issueLabel = IssueLabel(name: 'revert');
      pullRequest.labels = <IssueLabel>[issueLabel];
      githubService.pullRequestData = pullRequest;
      final ProcessMethod processMethod = await validationService.processPullRequestMethod(pullRequest);

      expect(processMethod, ProcessMethod.processRevert);
    });

    test('Should process message as revert when revert and autosubmit labels are present and pr is open', () async {
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(prNumber: 0, repoName: slug.name);
      final IssueLabel issueLabel = IssueLabel(name: 'revert');
      pullRequest.labels!.add(issueLabel);
      githubService.pullRequestData = pullRequest;
      final ProcessMethod processMethod = await validationService.processPullRequestMethod(pullRequest);

      expect(processMethod, ProcessMethod.processRevert);
    });

    test('Skip processing message when revert label exists and pr is closed', () async {
      final PullRequest pullRequest = generatePullRequest(prNumber: 0, repoName: slug.name);
      pullRequest.state = 'closed';
      final IssueLabel issueLabel = IssueLabel(name: 'revert');
      pullRequest.labels = <IssueLabel>[issueLabel];
      githubService.pullRequestData = pullRequest;
      final ProcessMethod processMethod = await validationService.processPullRequestMethod(pullRequest);

      expect(processMethod, ProcessMethod.doNotProcess);
    });
  });

  group('Specifying merge method via comment', () {
    late List<IssueComment> commentList;
    setUp(() {
      commentList = [];
      githubService.issueCommentsMockList = commentList;
    });

    test('No comment returns squash as default method.', () async {
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(
        slug: slug,
        prNumber: 1,
      );
      expect(MergeMethod.squash, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Finds merge method succesfully.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = '@autosubmit:rebase';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
        authorAssociation: 'MEMBER',
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(
        slug: slug,
        prNumber: 1,
      );
      expect(MergeMethod.rebase, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Multiple lines in single comment return last found merge method.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = '@autosubmit:rebase\n@autosubmit:merge';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(
        slug: slug,
        prNumber: 1,
      );
      expect(MergeMethod.merge, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Multiple comments return last found merge method.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = '@autosubmit:rebase';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
      );
      const String issueCommentBody2 = '@autosubmit:merge';
      final IssueComment issueComment2 = IssueComment(
        id: 2,
        body: issueCommentBody2,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      commentList.add(issueComment2);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(
        slug: slug,
        prNumber: 1,
      );
      expect(MergeMethod.merge, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Multiple comments, multiple lines in comment return last found merge method.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = '@autosubmit:rebase\n@autosubmit:merge';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
        authorAssociation: 'MEMBER',
      );
      const String issueCommentBody2 = '@autosubmit:squash\n@autosubmit:merge';
      final IssueComment issueComment2 = IssueComment(
        id: 2,
        body: issueCommentBody2,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      commentList.add(issueComment2);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(
        slug: slug,
        prNumber: 1,
      );
      expect(MergeMethod.merge, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Regex for merge method is case insensitive.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = '@autosubmit:Rebase';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
        authorAssociation: 'MEMBER',
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(
        slug: slug,
        prNumber: 1,
      );
      expect(MergeMethod.rebase, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Unknown merge method supplied returns squash as default.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = '@autosubmit:mrege';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(
        slug: slug,
        prNumber: 1,
      );
      expect(MergeMethod.squash, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Merge method found surounded by text.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = 'Please use @autosubmit:rebase. To avoid conflicts.';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(slug: slug, prNumber: 1);
      expect(MergeMethod.rebase, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Merge method default is returned in multiline regex.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = 'Please use @autosubmit:\nrebase. To avoid conflicts.';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(id: 1, body: issueCommentBody, authorAssociation: 'OWNER');
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(slug: slug, prNumber: 1);
      expect(MergeMethod.squash, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Merge method is default for empty comment.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = '';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(id: 1, body: issueCommentBody, authorAssociation: 'MEMBER');
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(slug: slug, prNumber: 1);
      expect(MergeMethod.squash, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Merge method is default for null comment.', () async {
      const String? issueCommentBody = null;
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
        authorAssociation: 'OWNER',
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(
        slug: slug,
        prNumber: 1,
      );
      expect(MergeMethod.squash, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('Merge method ignored for non-member and non-owner comment author.', () async {
      // This is to validate the changes made in the github repo for adding authorAssociation are correct here.
      const String issueCommentJson = '''
        {
          "id": 1376163336,
          "node_id": "IC_kwDOA8VHis5SBpYI",
          "user": {
            "login": "CaseyHillers",
            "id": 2148558,
            "node_id": "MDQ6VXNlcjIxNDg1NTg=",
            "site_admin": false
          },
          "created_at": "2023-01-09T19:22:07Z",
          "updated_at": "2023-01-09T19:22:07Z",
          "author_association": "COLLABORATOR",
          "body": "@autosubmit:rebase",
          "performed_via_github_app": null
        }
      ''';

      final IssueComment issueCommentFromJson = IssueComment.fromJson(json.decode(issueCommentJson));
      commentList.add(issueCommentFromJson);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(slug: slug, prNumber: 1);
      expect(MergeMethod.squash, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('With multiple merge method newest from non-owner, non-member is ignored.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = '@autosubmit:rebase';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
        authorAssociation: 'MEMBER',
      );
      const String issueCommentBody2 = '@autosubmit:merge';
      final IssueComment issueComment2 = IssueComment(
        id: 2,
        body: issueCommentBody2,
        authorAssociation: 'COLLABORATOR',
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      commentList.add(issueComment2);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(slug: slug, prNumber: 1);
      expect(MergeMethod.rebase, mergeMethod);
    });

    test('No authorAssociation with supplied merge method is ignored.', () async {
      const String issueCommentBody = '@autosubmit:merge';
      final IssueComment issueComment = IssueComment(
        id: 1,
        body: issueCommentBody,
      );
      commentList.add(issueComment);
      final MergeMethod mergeMethod = await validationService.checkForMergeMethod(
        slug: slug,
        prNumber: 1,
      );
      expect(MergeMethod.squash, mergeMethod);
    });
  });
}