| |
| More number for the questions about SSL overheads.... |
| |
| The following numbers were generated on a pentium pro 200, running linux. |
| They give an indication of the SSL protocol and encryption overheads. |
| |
| The program that generated them is an unreleased version of ssl/ssltest.c |
| which is the SSLeay ssl protocol testing program. It is a single process that |
| talks both sides of the SSL protocol via a non-blocking memory buffer |
| interface. |
| |
| How do I read this? The protocol and cipher are reasonable obvious. |
| The next number is the number of connections being made. The next is the |
| number of bytes exchanged bewteen the client and server side of the protocol. |
| This is the number of bytes that the client sends to the server, and then |
| the server sends back. Because this is all happening in one process, |
| the data is being encrypted, decrypted, encrypted and then decrypted again. |
| It is a round trip of that many bytes. Because the one process performs |
| both the client and server sides of the protocol and it sends this many bytes |
| each direction, multiply this number by 4 to generate the number |
| of bytes encrypted/decrypted/MACed. The first time value is how many seconds |
| elapsed doing a full SSL handshake, the second is the cost of one |
| full handshake and the rest being session-id reuse. |
| |
| SSLv2 RC4-MD5 1000 x 1 12.83s 0.70s |
| SSLv3 NULL-MD5 1000 x 1 14.35s 1.47s |
| SSLv3 RC4-MD5 1000 x 1 14.46s 1.56s |
| SSLv3 RC4-MD5 1000 x 1 51.93s 1.62s 1024bit RSA |
| SSLv3 RC4-SHA 1000 x 1 14.61s 1.83s |
| SSLv3 DES-CBC-SHA 1000 x 1 14.70s 1.89s |
| SSLv3 DES-CBC3-SHA 1000 x 1 15.16s 2.16s |
| |
| SSLv2 RC4-MD5 1000 x 1024 13.72s 1.27s |
| SSLv3 NULL-MD5 1000 x 1024 14.79s 1.92s |
| SSLv3 RC4-MD5 1000 x 1024 52.58s 2.29s 1024bit RSA |
| SSLv3 RC4-SHA 1000 x 1024 15.39s 2.67s |
| SSLv3 DES-CBC-SHA 1000 x 1024 16.45s 3.55s |
| SSLv3 DES-CBC3-SHA 1000 x 1024 18.21s 5.38s |
| |
| SSLv2 RC4-MD5 1000 x 10240 18.97s 6.52s |
| SSLv3 NULL-MD5 1000 x 10240 17.79s 5.11s |
| SSLv3 RC4-MD5 1000 x 10240 20.25s 7.90s |
| SSLv3 RC4-MD5 1000 x 10240 58.26s 8.08s 1024bit RSA |
| SSLv3 RC4-SHA 1000 x 10240 22.96s 11.44s |
| SSLv3 DES-CBC-SHA 1000 x 10240 30.65s 18.41s |
| SSLv3 DES-CBC3-SHA 1000 x 10240 47.04s 34.53s |
| |
| SSLv2 RC4-MD5 1000 x 102400 70.22s 57.74s |
| SSLv3 NULL-MD5 1000 x 102400 43.73s 31.03s |
| SSLv3 RC4-MD5 1000 x 102400 71.32s 58.83s |
| SSLv3 RC4-MD5 1000 x 102400 109.66s 59.20s 1024bit RSA |
| SSLv3 RC4-SHA 1000 x 102400 95.88s 82.21s |
| SSLv3 DES-CBC-SHA 1000 x 102400 173.22s 160.55s |
| SSLv3 DES-CBC3-SHA 1000 x 102400 336.61s 323.82s |
| |
| What does this all mean? Well for a server, with no session-id reuse, with |
| a transfer size of 10240 bytes, using RC4-MD5 and a 512bit server key, |
| a pentium pro 200 running linux can handle the SSLv3 protocol overheads of |
| about 49 connections a second. Reality will be quite different :-). |
| |
| Remeber the first number is 1000 full ssl handshakes, the second is |
| 1 full and 999 with session-id reuse. The RSA overheads for each exchange |
| would be one public and one private operation, but the protocol/MAC/cipher |
| cost would be quite similar in both the client and server. |
| |
| eric (adding numbers to speculation) |
| |
| --- Appendix --- |
| - The time measured is user time but these number a very rough. |
| - Remember this is the cost of both client and server sides of the protocol. |
| - The TCP/kernal overhead of connection establishment is normally the |
| killer in SSL. Often delays in the TCP protocol will make session-id |
| reuse look slower that new sessions, but this would not be the case on |
| a loaded server. |
| - The TCP round trip latencies, while slowing indervidual connections, |
| would have minimal impact on throughput. |
| - Instead of sending one 102400 byte buffer, one 8k buffer is sent until |
| - the required number of bytes are processed. |
| - The SSLv3 connections were actually SSLv2 compatable SSLv3 headers. |
| - A 512bit server key was being used except where noted. |
| - No server key verification was being performed on the client side of the |
| protocol. This would slow things down very little. |
| - The library being used is SSLeay 0.8.x. |
| - The normal mesauring system was commands of the form |
| time ./ssltest -num 1000 -bytes 102400 -cipher DES-CBC-SHA -reuse |
| This modified version of ssltest should be in the next public release of |
| SSLeay. |
| |
| The general cipher performace number for this platform are |
| |
| SSLeay 0.8.2a 04-Sep-1997 |
| built on Fri Sep 5 17:37:05 EST 1997 |
| options:bn(64,32) md2(int) rc4(idx,int) des(ptr,risc1,16,long) idea(int) blowfish(ptr2) |
| C flags:gcc -DL_ENDIAN -DTERMIO -O3 -fomit-frame-pointer -m486 -Wall -Wuninitialized |
| The 'numbers' are in 1000s of bytes per second processed. |
| type 8 bytes 64 bytes 256 bytes 1024 bytes 8192 bytes |
| md2 131.02k 368.41k 500.57k 549.21k 566.09k |
| mdc2 535.60k 589.10k 595.88k 595.97k 594.54k |
| md5 1801.53k 9674.77k 17484.03k 21849.43k 23592.96k |
| sha 1261.63k 5533.25k 9285.63k 11187.88k 11913.90k |
| sha1 1103.13k 4782.53k 7933.78k 9472.34k 10070.70k |
| rc4 10722.53k 14443.93k 15215.79k 15299.24k 15219.59k |
| des cbc 3286.57k 3827.73k 3913.39k 3931.82k 3926.70k |
| des ede3 1443.50k 1549.08k 1561.17k 1566.38k 1564.67k |
| idea cbc 2203.64k 2508.16k 2538.33k 2543.62k 2547.71k |
| rc2 cbc 1430.94k 1511.59k 1524.82k 1527.13k 1523.33k |
| blowfish cbc 4716.07k 5965.82k 6190.17k 6243.67k 6234.11k |
| sign verify |
| rsa 512 bits 0.0100s 0.0011s |
| rsa 1024 bits 0.0451s 0.0012s |
| rsa 2048 bits 0.2605s 0.0086s |
| rsa 4096 bits 1.6883s 0.0302s |
| |
